Published on July 20th, 2012 | by Chris0
Memorial Day (2011)
"It's Memorial Day, isn't it? What are we supposed to remember?"
I didn't recall this film being promoted in any significant way, and its a damn shame. Because Memorial Day has got to be one of the better war movies I've seen in a long, long time. I suppose my experience might have turned a bit subjective, but I suspect it would be that way for a lot of people.
We start with Kyle Vogel (Jonathan Bennett), just coming back from a tour in Iraq. During his stay in a military hospital, he tells his nurse all about his grandfather, and the events of one fateful Memorial Day in 1993, 10 years earlier.
Young Kyle (Jackson Bond) finds his grandfather Bud's (James Cromwell) footlocker full of mementos from his time in the 82nd Airborne in WWII. Reluctantly, Bud allows Kyle to pick three items from the chest, and he tells the story surrounding each one of them. The stories of course are done in flashback with Cromwell's son John taking the role of a young Lt. Vogel (quite convincingly I might add.)
Also told are a few stories of Kyle's tour in Iraq, with both complement and contrast the two's experiences in a very coherent manner. (I don't want to spoil any of these "stories", so lets just say they really are told quite well.)
On another level, its also about how the experiences of war affect you, for the rest of your life. How after all these years it still haunts Bud, and the immediate and future effects on Kyle.
As for my own experience of this movie, I found myself seeing a lot of my own family in this. Mainly because of James Cromwell and Mary Kay Fortier-Spalding's portrayal as the grandparents. The entire Vogel household reminded me so much of my own parents (both in appearance and mannerism), and grandparents that it was hard (in fact impossible) to step outside of that. The entire "don't talk to Grandpa about the war" bit, the German "sensibility" of "Opa" and "Oma" (man a few of those moments were familiar....) And at times, I wondered how many other people would see this in a similar light.
“Stories live forever — but only if you tell ’em.”
This movie also touched on something else I think is ultimately important, and in fact why this website even exists. Its through those war stories, and eventually, war movies that these stories are told, and put into a format so that we don't forget. So that we don't forget how completely awful and terrible it all is, and that we don't forget how important it can be, or why we do it in the first place. Right or wrong.
Honestly, if it weren't for some rather realistic depictions of wartime violence and injury I would recommend this for the younger audience who may not have that connection to a veteran of past wars. Those who really don't have anyone to tell them these kind of stories or can relate to events outside of a history book. I'd say that judgement is up to you as a parent.
I have to succumb to subjective feeling here and give Memorial Day a full 9/10. I don't do that very often. (Still haven't given a solid 10/10, not sure if that would ever happen. Me and my logarithmic scale!) It is designed to tug at all of your bits, and manages to pull every single one of them. At least it did mine.
Here's the trailer. I'm seriously considering putting this one on the shelf permanently, I thought it was that good.
Memorial Day [Blu-ray]
Sale Price: $5.95
You save: $12.02 (67%)
Eligible for free shipping!
Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days
When SSgt. Kyle Vogel leaves a handwritten letter on the seat of his car, grabs a pistol and steps into a Minnesota forest, we wonder who he is and what he's about to do. Flash back a few months as Vogel lies wounded in a hospital near Anbar Province, Iraq...
DVD InformationBinding: Blu-ray
Aspect Ratio: 1.77:1
Audience Rating: Unrated (Not Rated)
Brand: Image Entertainment
Manufacturer: IMAGE ENTERTAINMENT
Original Release Date:
- Jonathan Bennett
- James Cromwell
- John Cromwell
- Jackson Bond
- Factory sealed DVD
121 of 124 people found the following review helpful
Combat Veteran's Perspective,
This review is from: Memorial Day [Blu-ray] (Blu-ray)
This movie is a poignant characterization of the conflict that combat veterans live with, during and after their experiences. Focused on a WWII U.S. Paratrooper and his grandson it gives us a sense of the emotions that many combat veterans of all eras may go through - having to make a decision during a war that you know is going to end badly for someone and then having to live with your decision or in having friends be killed or injured. Anyone who has had a family member or friend who has seen combat can recognize the defensive wall that many veterans erect as their way of dealing with the experience. Hopefully this movie will encourage at least some of those veterans to allow their friends and family to try to understand.
75 of 77 people found the following review helpful
A must see for any generation!!,
Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Memorial Day (DVD)
I was lucky enough to see a screening of this film, and was blown away. To echo the reviews below, it's more than a war movie, it's a family movie. The movie crosses multiple generations, and encompasses stories from two wars. For those from the WWII generation this will bring back their own memories from a time with the war was very much part of their daily life. For those with loved ones serving now it gives a real face to what is happening. For everyone else it's a solid reminder that memories are stories that need to be shared, that burdens can't be carried alone and that all generations have something to give to one another.
Additionally, it teaches us that Memorial Day is more than a time for picnics and BBQ, more than just a free day off and a parade but that it's a day when we honor and remember.
I strongly recommend this for anyone, not just those with military ties
70 of 72 people found the following review helpful
Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Memorial Day (DVD)As a Marine veteran and grandfather, this film touched me on both counts. As a veteran, the meaning/importance of those small "souvenirs" one acquires during their time in service can be both cherished and guarded. This film approaches that importance with reverence without the carnage usually found in "military movies".
The closeness between the grandfather and his grandson was also touching and special. I am lucky to be very close to the only grandchild I have, a boy of 5 1/2. We have, since his birth, had a special relationship that continues to grow each day. I too have things to share with him someday.
Sometimes fathers, because of their role and lack of experience/wisdom, cannot share with their son, daughter, or other family members. With the years comes a realization of the memories tucked away which those "souvenirs" represent. This film helped in my confirmation of that.
I recommend this film to all Vet's and their families, and everyone... Read more
› See all 470 customer reviews...
Summary: "It's Memorial Day, isn't it? What are we supposed to remember?"