Published on June 7th, 2011 | by Chris1
Platoon (1986, Blu Ray)
I have to say, I was looking forward to seeing Oliver Stone's Platoon on Blu Ray for the first time. But you know what? It's still the same movie.
My original review of Platoon as a film I think is still pretty much spot on. But after four-and-a-half years (has it been that long? yikes!) I have to admit that I like it even less.
Yes it was groundbreaking for its day, as no other movie had come close to portraying the Vietnam War in a realistic fashion to that point. It is well acted, and well produced.... But the cliches present seem to become even more so with time. And some bits come out as downright corny today. Maybe its just me. Still a "must see" in the history of war movies, but in my opinion it hasn't aged well. If that makes sense.
Not to say there aren't some extremely well-done scenes, even if they're incredibly hard to watch. The 'village' sequence being the one that stands out in my mind.
But onto the Blu Ray. If you were expecting a "brand new" and "remastered" film that will completely blow you away (like the recent Apocalypse Now BD) you'll be disappointed. I'd say that this is a faithful and accurate representation of the movie as close as you're going to get to actual film. While the sound is indeed in DTS-HD, and it does sound great, it still isn't "spectacular" in its presentation. Probably due to the original mix and tech of the day. There are (more noticably) plenty of "stock" sound effects present, and if you watch the extras with the "raw" footage of some of the deleted scenes, the jungle-muted rifle cracks heard there sound more realistic to me than the dubbed over effects.
Visually, the film appears as it should, as it did in 1986. You're not going to get any great definition out of it. There is a lot of grain in this, as with most movies of the era. Just how it was. It's a fairly clean transfer, but there are some bits of dust flying by at times. The blacks are black as can be with no discernable "noise" and the brights are blinding. The early-on "jungle patrol ambush" is a good example of what it was supposed to look like on the big screen.
Final word: If you're a big fan of the movie (which I'm not so much) then this is a must-have. I'm on the fence as to if I will put this on my own shelf or not.
I can't comment so much on the extras, as I viewed a Netflix rental disc, and I don't know if there are differences between this and retail... All I watched extra-wise were the deleted scenes. Some of which I'm glad were dropped, and I hope Stone doesn't pull a Lucas and put some of these back in (like his comments would suggest), like the alternate "Barnes-lives" ending.
I'll keep my original 8/10. Just because of its significance and the bits I do find interesting in the movie....
Platoon (Two-Disc Blu-ray/DVD Combo)
Sale Price: $9.99
Eligible for free shipping!
Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days
Winner* of 4 Academy Awards®, including Best Picture, and based on the first-hand experience of Oscar®-winning director Oliver Stone, Platoon is powerful, intense and starkly brutal. "Harrowingly realistic and completely convincing" (Leonard Maltin), it is "a dark, unforgettable memorial" (The Washington Post) to every soldier whose innocence was lost in the war-torn jungles of Vietnam...
DVD InformationBinding: Blu-ray
Audience Rating: R (Restricted)
Manufacturer: MGM (Video & DVD)
Original Release Date:
- Charlie Sheen
- Tom Berenger
- Willem Dafoe
- Keith David
- Forest Whitaker
19 of 19 people found the following review helpful
Vietnam like it was,
This review is from: Platoon (Amazon Video)When I saw Platoon the first time I had trouble staying still. It seemed every five minutes, or so something on the screen would remind me of Nam. Finally, the last part of the movie , where they were overrun, I had to leave. My body was re-acting to the night, to the LP getting killed and the words of Vietnamese the North Vietnamese were yelling became too much. I started flashing back, because we had been overrun during TET68. My girlfriend stayed with me and at last got me calmed down( along with the Lorazepam my psychiatrist gave me) and we left.
It wasn't until the third time I watched it that I could sit all the way through, still wasn't easy. When you're overrun, just like the movie, you're filled with( what I called) Bloodlust! You are killing everything that doesn't look like an American. I don't have a lot of memories about it except for snippets of individual actions I was in. It's mass confusion and, like the movie, when the commanding officer expected that his... Read more
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
This review is from: Platoon (DVD)
Besides Apocalypse Now I cannot watch other VN era movies. There are no bad scenes or actors whose roles aren't fittingly defined and then portrayed. The Cherry, The Lifers. the LT caught between a rock and a hard place, The shorttimer, who is only getting shorter. The Kiss Ass getting his just desserts and the unspoken heroism of the everyday joe pulling or not pulling his weight. It's movie IMO that any veteran can immediately warm too. Who can forget the first day out of boot, getting immediately deployed. The sense of purpose and willingness. All rent asunder. A great movie. Anyone that's been forward deployed will immediately warm to this. Those that never served will get a taste from the portrayed experiences. As good as it gets.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
Platoon has become a classic war movie like Saving Private Ryan,
This review is from: Platoon (Amazon Video)Platoon has become a classic war movie like Saving Private Ryan, Apocalypse Now, and Flags of Our Fathers. It is still as emotionally engulfing and relevant today as it was when it was first released in 1986 when I first saw it. So what is the legacy of this Academy Award winning film for Best Picture. The Vietnam soldiers portrayed by Tom Berenger, Willem Dafoe, Charlie Sheen, Keith David, Forrest Whitaker, Reggie Johnson, Kevin Dillion and John C. McGinley are all vivid and memorable. The jungle cinematography, battle scenes and heavy, ominous musical score is still as riveting today as it was thirty years ago. So, its acting, directing, cinematography, and musical score ranks it in the top 10 war films of all time.
Back when this movie was first released, many people viewed it as an "unpatriotic, anti-war" movie. But now in retrospect, Oliver Stone was paying tribute to the common field soldier who had to endure a tragic existence in a war that is now... Read more
› See all 1,237 customer reviews...
Summary: Still a "must see" in the history of war movies, but in my opinion it hasn't aged well.