Published on June 2nd, 2011 | by Chris1
Battle For Haditha (2007)
Battle for Haditha is a faux-documentary-style movie based on a true event, the November 2005 'retribution' attack on a group of Iraqi civilians after an IED attack. It really isn't *that* bad of a movie, but quite frankly, it just pissed me off... bigtime.
The first part of the movie is just build up to the actual attack. It's slow, to be honest. To the point I was starting to wonder if anything was actually going to happen. To their credit, the filmmakers pull off the "faux documentary" style thing quite well, actually (a lot) better than the similar (and awful) Redacted. It doesn't have nearly the stilted and staged feel to it that Redacted had.
But, the way that this story unfolds, and is told just really, really pissed me off. The Marines here are portrayed basically as bloodthirsty idiots, running around shooting anything that moves and appearing to enjoy it.
OK, sure, I will give you that it was a terrible, tragic event, that never should have happened. But the way its done here does nothing but sensationalize it further. Even the attempt to show remorse on behalf of the IED perpetrators comes across as only half-heart-felt. Leading me to believe that the purpose of this film is not solely a typical 'anti-war' treatise, but rather a Redacted-style "baby killer!" reaction piece.
One of the final scenes does show one of the Marines appearing to maybe, possibly, realize what they've done and offer a half-assed hand as an apology....
I don't know the truth behind the story here. Maybe it really went down like this, I can't say. Only those that were there can really say for sure, but I can't say I recommend this picture to anyone, really, unless you enjoy getting more pissed off by the minute. I don't question the motives behind this movie, they are painfully clear, but there's a point where you start shouting, "enough! I get it already!" The trailer below claims "There are many ways to see the same story," but quite frankly this only seems to be one of them.
On the plus side, I will give them points for production value, though. (and the only reason it gets a 5 from me) I'm not sure where this was filmed (I didn't spend a lot of time on research) but its pretty convincing, but I'm no expert.
Battle For Haditha
Sale Price: $7.99
Eligible for free shipping!
Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours
Battle For Haditha -November 19th 2005, Haditha, IraqIraqi insurgents bomb a convoy of US Marines, resulting in the death of theirmost popular officer. Enraged by this loss, his young Marine buddies carry out abrutal retaliation...
DVD InformationBinding: DVD
Aspect Ratio: 2.35:1
Audience Rating: Unrated
Brand: Image Entertainment
Manufacturer: Fisher Klingenstein Films
Original Release Date:
- Matthew Knoll
- Elliot Ruiz
- Eric Mehalacopoulos
- Nathan De La Cruz
- Andrew McLaren
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful
Don't waste your time or money,
Typical anti-military Liberal propaganda. Don't waste your time or money, It was free for me through Prime and I still couldn't tolerate it for more than 30 minutes.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
Only some one like Obama or Hilary Clinton would be that childishly reckless with lives.,
I don't even know where to start. It's inaccurate, sloppy, and so out of bounds it's reprehensible. If I had been depicted in this film I would sue for defamation of character or slander. The enemy does not act that pleasant. The military can not and does not give orders to do the things they did. Not even the Marines would go that far. Only some one like Obama or Hilary Clinton would be that vengeful and childishly reckless with lives. Had the our men really done this they would not have gotten out of that area alive.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
Watch some embedded military documentaries from multiple biases first,
Yes, the overarching events portrayed in this movie transpired. No, I was not there and I highly doubt the writer and director were there either. In fact, I highly doubt the writer or director of this film have ever stepped foot in a military base, an area of conflict, let alone a battlefield as complex as Haditha.
I've never been moved enough to write a review on a movie but I feel it necessary to point out the outright garbage this one was.
- I loved the whole picture approach this movie utilized. It took into account and portrayed the events and lives from multiple perspectives and cultures (accurately or not the idea was strong).
- The acting by some cast members was great, most were tolerable, some were just bad.
- The cinematography was amateurish at best. They attempted a documentary / embedded feel either intentionally or accidentally. Either way it was a disaster
-... Read more
› See all 189 customer reviews...
Summary: I don't know the truth behind the story here. Maybe it really went down like this, I can't say. Only those that were there can really say for sure, but I can't say I recommend this picture to anyone, really, unless you enjoy getting more pissed off by the minute.