Published on April 20th, 2011 | by Chris0
In 1995 Showtime released this miniseries/docudrama about the events leading up to, and including the atomic bomb drops on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. The short version: It's not bad, but its not great, either.
The facts are pretty well known, as is the story, so I won't even attempt to lay it all out here. The movie starts with the death of FDR, and from that point on focuses mostly on President Truman as he is (and his staff are) presented with the details of this new secret superweapon and the struggle with the decision on if, when, and how to use it.
Then there's the Japanese viewpoint, which, while present, doesn't seem to be as well thought out. Why exactly I can't say.
Overall I think it presents a pretty good estimation of what Truman was handed, and what it might have been like for him and his staff, to have to make such a decision. Ultimately, as history, and this film would portray it was a decision that once made, proved to be the right one, and one that he didn't regret.
I did appreciate that, for the most part, it didn't descend into a giant anti-nuke anti-war treatise. It stuck to its guns as a historical docudrama, and managed to present the various sides to the story without necessarily favoring one over another.
The actors chosen for their respective roles did an excellent job in portraying the people as we have become accustomed to seeing them in newsreels, etc. At first, it would seem that Kenneth Welsh's portrayal of Truman is wooden and, I dunno, absent... But paired up against actual footage it seems pretty spot on. Wesley Addy is particularly good, IMO, in his role as War Dept. Secretary Henry Stimson and his objections to using such a weapon.
Also of note are the (all too) infrequent interviews with people who were involved either with the Manhattan project itself, the US government/armed forces, and with bomb survivors and former Japanese military. These should have been either more prominent, or left on the floor entirely. While they did add a lot to the experience, there just wasn't enough of it for my tastes.
The entire package is quite lengthy, weighing in at approximately 3 hrs., but its necessary to get everything in there, so fair warning! It actually doesn't feel like 3 hrs once you get into it. It's paced well enough and incorporates enough of the side-stories that it manages to hold your interest throughout. The only reason I say above that its not great, is that it is rather flat, and while people may be portrayed accurately, its done without a lot of depth or emotion.
I would actually recommend this as an education piece, either at home or in school. I don't recall anything except for maybe a few passing instances of profanity that might prevent it from being used as such.
I would also recommend viewing the Japanese film, Japan's Longest Day, as a bookend, companion piece, or counterpoint (depending on your own persuasions) to this film, as it provides an almost parallel and much more complete look at what was going on there during this same period. The Sun might be included in that as well.
Sale Price: $29.95
Eligible for free shipping!
Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days
THE GRIZZLY EVENTS LEADING TO THE FIRST ATTACK WITH A NUCLEAR WEAPON.
DVD InformationBinding: DVD
Audience Rating: NR (Not Rated)
Brand: PLATINUM DISC LLC
Manufacturer: Echo Bridge
Original Release Date:
- Kenneth Welsh
- Naohiko Umewaka
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
Living in a dreamworld, blind to a nightmare,
This review is from: Hiroshima (DVD)Having been kept on the sidelines during the war, Harry S Truman ascended to the presidency with no privileged information as to the state of the war and of the war effort. He was immediately briefed about the Manhattan Project and the atomic weapon being developed. Truman sought the opinion of his cabinet members but kept his own counsel, conscious as he was of the weight of the responsbility that had fallen on him and on him alone.
At the other end of the world, the Japanese Cabinet is debating how to end the war. The military bully the cabinet and refuse to even consider unconditional surrender, believing that America's strength will fail when the Japanese people fight to the death defending their homeland. The civilian cabinet members bluntly tell the military they live in a dreamworld.
The Allies issue the Potsdam Declaration, reiterating their demand for unconditional surrender. In order to keep the military from plunging the country into domestic chaos,... Read more
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
Unheralded MASTERPIECE. Where's the Blu-Ray?,
This review is from: Hiroshima (DVD)After watching "Hiroshima" again over the President's Day weekend, I feel compelled to go public with my awestruck praise and appreciation for this knockout 1995 Showtime production, a totally unique hybrid of newsreel documentary, dramatic re-enactment, and modern survivors' testimony about the end of WWII and the new world the atomic bombs inaugurated.
For us fans of the humanities (art, music, history) this production is a feast of spiraling drama and consequential real-life impact. Truman's decision to use the atomic bomb to force the Japanese to surrender and end WWII remains a HIGHLY controversial choice. Here it is all laid out over three riveting hours, examining ALL the political, strategic and moral choices that had to converge to arrive at that terrifying hour of 8:15 AM, August 6th 1945, when the bomb bay doors opened on the Enola Gay and the "Fat Man" was dropped on Hiroshima.
I recommend "Hiroshima" not only to those of us... Read more
This review is from: Hiroshima (DVD)
This is a balanced, un-biased view of the controversy over using the atomic bombs on Japan. Mostly reenactments, obviously made-up dialogue based on historical fact, with documentary footage, and a small number of interviews of the people involved. A behind-the-scenes account of what was going on with the leaders of the day. Truman and Hirohito look-alike actors made this seem more palatable. Overall an entertaining movie, while being profound and sobering. The Japanese army was in control, with the politicians unable to control them. Those leading the army were hell-bent on having the country fight to the death of every man, woman, and child. And the country was behind them with an almost religious fanaticism to honor the Emperor in this way, even though the Emperor and the Prime Minister wanted to give up the fight.
› See all 58 customer reviews...
Summary: It stuck to its guns as a historical docudrama, and managed to present the various sides to the story without necessarily favoring one over another.