Published on February 17th, 2011 | by Chris2
Hearts and Minds (1974)
If you watch no other documentary about the Vietnam war, you should make it 1974's Hearts and Minds. It's a chilling look at what (even then) was known about what was going on over there, and how it all never should have happened in the first place.
First off, realize that this movie is decidely anti-Vietnam war. I don't think there is any doubt to the purpose of the movie. However, I think they did a fine job of exploring the facts (as it suited this purpose) and even providing a sort of tribute to the many casualties.
One of the prominent names is Navy pilot and long-term POW George Coker. Throughout the movie he is shown not condemning the war per-se, nor really being "for it" in the traditional sense of things. Rather he's shown in the light I think we should see guys like him, doing the job he was called on to do, and that's about as good a tribute as it gets.
Also prominent throughout is the use of key Presidential soundbites and historical events, from Truman all the way through to Nixon. When pieced together like they've done here, it paints a picture that we now know is all too common. One of the US meddling in foreign affairs where it shouldn't be, and feeding the American people, well, a line of BS a mile long.
I'm only touching on a couple aspects of the movie here, as there are really too many too mention in any detail. The views of the draft evaders, the people at home, the people of Vietnam, and the soldiers both on the ground and the ones who returned.... It's pretty sobering and disheartening, and even more so when you consider that this was made *right then*, that it didn't take years for all of this to come out. It's unfortunate that it has taken years, if not decades for the truth to become accepted, but the reality that these facts were indeed known at the time, at least to a few, is saddening.
No matter what your views on the Vietnam war, whether you are old enough to remember or not, I think you'll probably learn a great deal from Hearts and Minds. It manages to do its job without (most) of the usual "War is Bad(tm)" generic rhetoric. Yeah, it gets close at times, most notably the scene of the NVA soldier's funeral, but facts is facts, and its portrayed in just that manner.
Be sure to watch all the way through the end of the credits, to the end of the parade scene at the end. I think it sums up perfectly what public opinion must have been, with everyone arguing and nobody really knowing the truth.
Hearts and Minds (The Criterion Collection)
Sale Price: $119.89
Eligible for free shipping!
Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours
A courageous and startling film, Peter Davis' landmark documentary Hearts and Minds unflinchingly confronts the United States' involvement in Vietnam. Using a wealth of sources-from interviews to newsreels to documentary footage of the conflict at home and abroad-Davis constructs a powerfully affecting portrait of the disastrous effects of war...
DVD InformationBinding: DVD
Aspect Ratio: 1.85:1
Audience Rating: R (Restricted)
Original Release Date:
- Dwight D. Eisenhower
- William Marshall
- Georges Bidault
- Les Brown
- Clark Clifford
Amazing documentary! You must have the guts to watch ...,
This review is from: Hearts and Minds (The Criterion Collection) (DVD)
Amazing documentary! You must have the guts to watch it, though. We're more used to watching scenes like this in movies and you always have the chance of thinking "They're just fiction" ... you can't do that in a documentary. That's why it is so shocking. Highly recommendable!
17 of 18 people found the following review helpful
Best Possible 2 Hour Course on the Viet Nam War,
This review is from: Hearts and Minds [VHS] (VHS Tape)I'm not sure how manytimes I've viewed this documentary. 25? 30? Every time I teach my course on the Viet Nam war, showing Hearts & Minds is the 1st thing I do. Somewhere in the course, I ask students whether it gives a balanced picture of the war or whether it is anit-war. The debate always is lively and classes tend to be somewhat evenly divided. Without question, this is one of the very best documentaries ever made. If someone wants to learn about the war in Viet Nam and can devote only two hours, seeing this docmentary is not the best, it is the only thing to do.
Regarding the reviewer who argues for editing it to shorten, reorganize and omit the nudity, I could not disagree more. Students sit spell bound for the full two hours, then ask to view it again. The redundancy, such as it is, is minimal as well as valuable. The scenes with the prostitutes are important because they show how we dehumanized the people; women in particular were seen by many as little more... Read more
20 of 21 people found the following review helpful
Where Did the Angry Young Warriors Go?,
By A Customer
This review is from: Hearts and Minds [VHS] (VHS Tape)I had the opportunity to be with one of the angry young warriors featured in this documentary when he was hurt on June 29, 1966. It is amazing to watch him as this documentary played out, and to then realize that after that difficult period, this angry young African American amputee became a parent of five, and a counselor for a generation of youth from the inner city of Detroit. The experience of all who made the walk in Vietnam was life-changing and often truly traumatic. However, one should pause and reflect - where did they all go afterwards? In the case of William Marshall, he overcame his anger (or at least recognized his anger and put it to constructive work) and became a great asset to the city of Detroit. As you watch this great film, I would challenge you to realize that some are able to use these tragedies to recover, rebuild and pass on personal character, and obviously, some are not. It has been 31-plus years since Charlie Morris (deceased Medal of Honor winner from... Read more
› See all 79 customer reviews...
Summary: No matter what your views on the Vietnam war, whether you are old enough to remember or not, I think you'll probably learn a great deal from Hearts and Minds.