Published on December 14th, 2007 | by Chris2
Casualties of War (1989)
Where do I even begin? With the recent release of Redacted, director Brian DePalma has resurrected the spectre of the evil that men do during wartime. Without going into great detail as to the failure of Redacted, I'll rather go into the huge success that his earlier telling of the true and near-identical story, Casualties of War, is.
Fresh into the Nam is PFC Eriksson (Michael J. Fox), who witnesses (along with the rest of his squad) his friend "Brownie" killed by an enemy sniper.
His squad, Sgt. Meserve (Sean Penn), Clark (Don Harvey), and "Hatch" (John C. Reilly) decide to take revenge by kidnapping a Vietnamese girl (Thuy Thu Le) and, to put it kindly, treat her as "the spoils of war." Eriksson stands as the voice of reason of the bunch, against it from the beginning, and refuses to take part in any of the evil deeds. Brownie's replacement, Diaz (John Leguizamo) plays the "on the fence" character, who eventually (whether out of fear or just peer pressure) also damns himself with his actions.
When the girl eventually threatens to expose them in their real mission, Eriksson fires off a few rounds to prevent her from being killed, and in the melee, she's killed anyway. He returns to basecamp, and reports the matter to his superiors, Lt. Reilly (Ving Rhames) and Capt. Hill (Dale Dye.) The system doesn't do anything, and after being nearly fragged by the squad, he eventually tells his tale to a nosy chaplain, who apparently escalates the matter up the chain of command. Hollywood military adviser Dale Dye takes on a more prominent role than his usual cameo here as the representative of the military status quo.
The squad is convicted and sentenced. But the true redemption of Eriksson happens sometime latter as he helps a young Vietnamese student much later in life, and she tells him "its over now."
Casualties of War isn't exactly one of those movies you enjoy watching, at least not for the usual reasons. As the typical morality-play it succeeds and surpasses. The sole voice of justice and decency prevails, and there are some choice quotes by Eriksson that define the essence of what this picture is about, such as "Everybody's acting like we can do anything and it don't matter what we do. Maybe we gotta' be extra careful because maybe it matters more than we even know."
The performances are just stellar, from Fox's character, to Penn's madman, Reilly's typical dipstick, Harvey's psycho, and Leguizamo's floundering.... They each represent aspects of the fog and character of war that exist, whether we like it or not. The resulting attempt by the system to suppress these evil deeds, and the obvious oxymorons (we're *supposed* to be killers!) that present themselves in the trial.... all make Casualties of War a top-notch example of what an anti-war movie should be about. From a film standpoint and a classical storytelling standpoint.
It's plain to see that Redacted is nothing more than an ugly re-hash of Casualties of War. Yes they are both based on true stories, and its unfortunate that nothing's changed as it relates to the awfulness of war. Where Casualties differs though is in the ultimate triumph of good over evil, and in the redemption of the main character. Where Redacted ends with the one "good guy" crying in his beer and a slideshow of bloody corpses. How the mighty have fallen.
Casualties of War (Unrated Extended Cut)
Sale Price: $4.69
You save: $5.30 (53%)
Eligible for free shipping!
Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days
Hailed by critics as a masterpiece, CASUALTIES OF WAR is based on the true story of a squad of soldiers caught in the moral quagmire of wartime Vietnam. Witness to a vile crime, Private Eriksson (Michael J...
DVD InformationBinding: DVD
Aspect Ratio: 2.40:1
Audience Rating: Unrated (Not Rated)
Manufacturer: Sony Pictures Home Entertainment
Original Release Date:
- Sean Penn
- Michael J. Fox
- Don Harvey
- John Reilly
- John Leguizamo
13 of 13 people found the following review helpful
"This ain't the army, Sarge.",
This review is from: Casualties of War (DVD)Brian De Palma's "Casualties of War" is not easy to watch, even for the most seasoned of "cineastes". Under the influence of war and the warmakers human beings are capable of behavior that defies comprehension. And the behavior of these men, with the mysterious exception of Pvt Errikson (Michael J. Fox), is indeed beyond comprehension.
How any decent veteran or man could object to this film also defies comprehension. It is not anti-military or anything of that kind. On the contrary, one would have to say after a thorough review of the actual story behind the rape, torture and murder of this Vietnamese girl (she was between the ages of 16 and 18), Pvt Errikson (whoever he really is) is an example of the greatest and most courageous form of patriotism: an attempt, even in the deadliest of situations, to uphold the Constituion and military law under the most dire of circumstances. Sean Penn plays Sgt. Meserve, a terrifying Platoon leader who, after suffering a loss in his... Read more
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful
The Vietnam Experience,
This review is from: Casualties of War (Unrated Extended Cut) (DVD)I watched this movie long ago and don't remember all the scenes, but I just got it in the mail today and thought I should say a few things about this movie. I like it and it has plenty of action in it and all, but unlike some other low-star reviews, this movie does not portray ALL American soldiers as murderers and rapists. In Vietnam, there were a few GI's who were a little f**ked in the head and what they did to quite a few Vietnamese villagers in revenge for their buddies being killed went far beyond the ways of justice. Take the My Lai incident in '68 when 2Lt. Calley's platoon was responsible for murdering over 500 villagers, including rape cases on a few people too. Not every American soldier in that platoon decided to get involved, but there are a few nutcases that decided to not let anything stop them in their goal of vengeance. So I remember that this movie didn't recklessly place the average American soldier in the level of some wannabe criminal. Soldiers like Michael J... Read more
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful
This review is from: Casualties of War (Unrated Extended Cut) (DVD)
This movie is allegedly based on true events, with identities altered.
I don't know about the particular events of this movie, but - - - ,
I spent two years as a soldier in the old Republic of Viet Nam, and yes, guys did find themselves caught in situations requiring courageous choices during a moral crisis, and yes, some guys were murdered by their fellow soldiers.
I reckon I ought to know.
"Been there, done that."
› See all 161 customer reviews...
Summary: Casualties of War is a top-notch example of what an anti-war movie should be about. From a film standpoint and a classical storytelling standpoint.