Redacted (2007)

Wow.  I’d like to thank Brian DePalma for the experience that was Redacted.  I can really say I am totally blown away.

…Blown away at just how completely awful this movie is.  There aren’t words to describe the awfulness that is this… this thing.  I’m not even sure where to start.  But that’s not going to stop me from trying.

[SNIP]

I had written this big, long, ranting, multi-part, manifesto-like ….thing, which I’ve subsequently erased, errr redacted even.  (I’ll take irony for $200 Alex!)  I’m not going to go there.

I think that’s what DePalma wants from Redacted.  A reaction.  Any reaction.  Like a rotten kid being rotten solely to get attention.  “Hey look! I’m still here!”  Well, I think you’re going to get it, but not from me.  I’ll not recommend this movie to anyone, except as an example of a purely bad piece of failed art/film school schtick.  The writing: bad. The acting: bad.  Production: didn’t like it.  If it didn’t have DePalma’s name on it we’d be poo-poo-ing this off for what it is. The whole faux-documentary thing has yet to be pulled off convincingly, and this is definitely yet another example.

1989’s similarly themed Casualties of War was a good movie.  In a lot of ways.  This?  This is just a poor rehash.  It is wailing and finger pointing and DePalma yelling at our current crop of vets, “Baby Killer!”.  You should know better than that.  Especially coming from your generation.

I challenge you, Brian.  You want to make a documentary about how war sucks on all sides, and is somewhat fair to both sides, then do that.  Get your ass out there “in the suck” and do that.  Even if you want to make one about how it sucks for only one side, like Redacted, then do that, too.  But don’t “imagine” and don’t pretend.  Because thats a word that is closely related to “pretentious,” which is exactly what I think of Redacted.

And I’d also like to thank you, Mr. DePalma, for allowing me to hand out my first single star.  And hopefully my last.  Don’t bother with Redacted.

Technorati Tags: war movie reviews, redacted, 2007, iraq, samarra, brian depalma

Related posts:

1. Redacted on HDNet Movies Tonight
2. Brian DePalma’s ‘Redacted’
3. Another Take on “Redacted”
4. ‘Redacted’ set to show at NY Festival
5. The Four Horsemen (2007)
6. The War (2007)
7. Delta Farce (2007)
8. Lions For Lambs (2007)
9. In The Valley of Elah (2007)
10. Casualties of War (1989)

This entry was posted on Thursday, November 15th, 2007 at 7:25 am and is filed under 2000s, Iraq Movies, Reviews. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.