Redacted (2007)

Thursday, November 15, 2007

WMB Rating:½☆☆☆☆
User Rating: 1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Loading ... Loading ...

Redacted2007Wow.  I'd like to thank Brian DePalma for the experience that was Redacted.  I can really say I am totally blown away.

...Blown away at just how completely awful this movie is.  There aren't words to describe the awfulness that is this... this thing.  I'm not even sure where to start.  But that's not going to stop me from trying.

[SNIP]

I had written this big, long, ranting, multi-part, manifesto-like ....thing, which I've subsequently erased, errr redacted even.  (I'll take irony for $200 Alex!)  I'm not going to go there.

I think that's what DePalma wants from Redacted.  A reaction.  Any reaction.  Like a rotten kid being rotten solely to get attention.  "Hey look! I'm still here!"  Well, I think you're going to get it, but not from me.  I'll not recommend this movie to anyone, except as an example of a purely bad piece of failed art/film school schtick.  The writing: bad. The acting: bad.  Production: didn't like it.  If it didn't have DePalma's name on it we'd be poo-poo-ing this off for what it is. The whole faux-documentary thing has yet to be pulled off convincingly, and this is definitely yet another example.

1989's similarly themed Casualties of War was a good movie.  In a lot of ways.  This?  This is just a poor rehash.  It is wailing and finger pointing and DePalma yelling at our current crop of vets, "Baby Killer!".  You should know better than that.  Especially coming from your generation.

I challenge you, Brian.  You want to make a documentary about how war sucks on all sides, and is somewhat fair to both sides, then do that.  Get your ass out there "in the suck" and do that.  Even if you want to make one about how it sucks for only one side, like Redacted, then do that, too.  But don't "imagine" and don't pretend.  Because thats a word that is closely related to "pretentious," which is exactly what I think of Redacted.

And I'd also like to thank you, Mr. DePalma, for allowing me to hand out my first single star.  And hopefully my last.  Don't bother with Redacted.

Technorati Tags: , , , , ,

Redacted Redacted
List Price: $19.98
Sale Price: $4.35
You save: $15.63 (78%)
  Eligible for free shipping!
Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days

Description

A fictional story inspired by true events REDACTED is a unique cinematic experience that will force viewers to radically reconsider the filters through which we see and accept events in our world the power of the mediated image and how presentation and composition influence our ideas and beliefs. A profound meditation on the way information is packaged distributed and received in an era with infinite channels of communication REDACTED utilizes a variety of created source material video diaries produced documentary surveillance footage online testimonials news pieces to comment on the extreme disconnect between the surface of an image and the reality of ideas and the truth especially in times of strife.Centered around a small group of American soldiers stationed at a checkpoint in Iraq REDACTED alternates points of view balancing the experiences of these young men under duress and members of the media with those of the local Iraqi people illuminating how each have been deeply affected by the current conflict and their encounters with each other. The charged apotheosis of Brian De Palma s filmmaking career REDACTED caps off a body of work which has explored the politics of image-making and reception more fully than any living filmmaker.System Requirements:Running Time: 90 minutesFormat: DVD MOVIE Genre: DRAMA/MILITARY & WAR Rating: R UPC: 876964001229 Manufacturer No: 10122

Brian De Palma’s ferocious Redacted is one of a number of cinematic protests against the Iraq War and the withholding of information and images about the war from the U.S. public. But it is also shares De Palma’s perennial interest in the relationship between film and violence, a relationship that has changed significantly in the real world because of the Internet, cable news, and the ubiquity of camcorders on the ground in Iraq. In a world more intent than ever on watching everything, De Palma has fashioned Redacted to look like a daisy chain of found footage taken from disparate sources. These include an American soldier’s video journal (which, not insignificantly, is also supposed to be that soldier’s audition piece for film school), a French documentary, a security camera at the edge of an army compound, and streaming video online from insurgents and military families alike. Taken together, Redacted recreates the kind of Iraq War scenes we’ve heard about for years: soldiers kidnapped or felled by booby traps, pregnant women and children shot by American guards at military checkpoints because Iraqi drivers misunderstand orders, etc. With mood and setting firmly established, Redacted then tells the story of an atrocity ripped from headlines in 2006: the rape and murder of an Iraqi teen, as well as the murder of her family, by American soldiers who then proceed to cover up their crime. Meanwhile, other soldiers, well-meaning witnesses to what happened, implode with doubt and uncertainty about what to do. In a way, Redacted is really about the paralysis of ordinary Americans confronted by the horror of our collective misjudgment about Iraq. It's a work of fiction using actors, meaning that De Palma employs a verisimilitude which sometimes doesn’t sit well with anyone who has seen a lot of Iraq War documentaries featuring real troops and real Iraqis. But De Palma is trying to do something very difficult, i.e., make the case that in war, truth really is the first casualty. --Tom Keogh

DVD Information

Binding: DVD
Aspect Ratio: 1.78:1
Audience Rating: R (Restricted)
Brand: MAGNOLIA HOME ENTERTAINMENT
Manufacturer: Magnolia
Original Release Date:
Actors:
  • Patrick Carroll
  • Rob Devaney
  • Izzy Diaz
  • Ty Jones
  • Anas Wellman

Reviews

Related Posts with Thumbnails

Related posts:

  1. Redacted on HDNet Movies Tonight
  2. Brian DePalma’s ‘Redacted’
  3. Another Take on “Redacted”
  4. ‘Redacted’ set to show at NY Festival
  5. Battle For Haditha (2007)
  6. The Four Horsemen (2007)
  7. Lions For Lambs (2007)
  8. Delta Farce (2007)
  9. In The Valley of Elah (2007)
  10. CNN on “War Films”

3 Responses to “Redacted (2007)”

  1. [EDIT: Read the full WMB Review of 'Redacted' here....]

    I won’t comment much on this, I’ll just report the news…Brian DePalma’s latest film is quite a departure from the over-the-top thrillers and gangster movies for which he is best known. “Redacted

    #40
  2. Where do I even begin?  With the recent release of Redacted, director Brian DePalma has resurrected the spectre of the evil that men do during wartime.  Without going into great detail as to the failure of Redacted, I’ll rather go into the huge

    #41
  3. A pair of war movies make their DVD debuts today, without any further….In The Valley of Elah (2007)A career officer (Jones) and his wife (Sarandon) work with a police
    detective (Theron) to uncover the truth behind their son’s
    disappearance following h

    #46

Leave a Reply